Friday, September 4, 2015

Girl Meets Course-Correction


Girl Meets World got good. What gives?


Wednesday, July 29, 2015

A Dream Cast for the CW's New Gritty Dystopian Little Women Adaptation

In case you haven't heard (you poor thing), the CW is developing a TV show based on Little Women. And the description... well, I'd say it defies words, but it's made of words, so just read it:
Written by [Alexis] Jolly, Little Women is described as a hyper-stylized, gritty adaptation of the 1868 novel by Louisa May Alcott, in which disparate half-sisters Jo, Meg, Beth, and Amy band together in order to survive the dystopic streets of Philadelphia and unravel a conspiracy that stretches far beyond anything they have ever imagined – all while trying not to kill each other in the process.
Every time I think I know how I feel about that description, it turns out I was wrong. Am I horrified? Excited? Anxious? Confused? I have no idea! All I know is one thing: This show absolutely must be made real. I don't know that a gritty, dystopian Little Women TV show is something that needed to happen, but now that the idea's out there, it had better happen. And it honestly has a better shot--both at being picked up and at being good--on the CW, a network that is currently experiencing something of a golden era of female-driven shows, literary adaptation shows, and genre shows, than it would on any other channel.

While we wait to see what happens, though, my sister and I have decided to prod the CW along with the widely-recognized gold standard of anticipatory fannish activity: a fantasy cast. So look no further, dear reader; you have found the One True Gritty Dystopian Little Women Cast Line-Up.


Emily Kinney as Meg March

http://assets-s3.usmagazine.com/uploads/assets/articles/80404-emily-kinney-talks-shocking-walking-dead-midseason-finale-plot-twist/1417464924_emily-kinney-zoom.jpg 

The eldest of the March sisters, Meg provides stability, kindness, and a guiding hand, while hiding an independent streak behind a strong sense of propriety. Kinney has proved herself more than capable of playing a sweet character with a steel spine--and her trademark is bringing sympathy and warmth to a gritty, post-apocalyptic setting setting.


Lindsey Morgan as Jo March


Second child Jo March, the lead of the book, is the wild card of the March family. She's smart, loud, brash, has zero sense of propriety, and is the least warm and nurturing of the four March sisters. And she has a serious temper. But she would do anything for her family. People who've seen The 100 (I know you're out there!) will recognize that as a pretty spot-on description of Morgan's character Raven Reyes. It'd be a wrench to lose her from that show, but she'd kill on Little Women.


Amandla Stenberg as Beth March


Beth is the quietest of the March sisters. Sweet, generous, and incredibly family-oriented, her rebellious streak shines through only when she's standing up on behalf of someone else. Stenberg's been adding quiet humanity to brutal post-apocalypses since 2012.


Kiernan Shipka as Amy March
 
http://i.imgur.com/ljCHfMy.jpg 

Youngest child Amy is self-obsessed, a little bit vain, and cares a lot about appearances--but without the same understanding of propriety that Meg has. She's impulsive and self-centered, but when her sisters set her straight, she'll do the right thing. Because Amy, like all the March sisters, does care deeply about family. Alone of the four actresses playing the March sisters, Shipka did not make her name in a post-apocalyptic movie or show. But she did a phenomenal job on Mad Men portraying a young girl growing and maturing in a restrictive society.


Susanna Thompson as Marmee


Marmee was the original rebel of the March family--that's where her daughters got it from. She loved her children fiercely, and wanted the world for them, but she respected their independence above all else. And she never believed that their gender should hold them back. Thompson has played more than one ferocious mother in her time, and fans of the CW's Arrow should have no trouble imagining her as the March matriarch. Moira Queen may be more cut-throat than Marmee, but the family dedication is definitely there.


John Cho as John Brooke

http://www.dramafever.com/st/news/images/Selfie_1.png 

John Brooke is Meg's love interest, a sweet, solid, studious, and upstanding man of limited means. John Cho is amazing, makes everyone who watches his shows want to hug him, and needs to be in more things. No-brainer.


Ian Harding as Theodore "Laurie" Laurence


Laurie starts out the book as an impetuous, spoiled, but ultimately good-hearted friend of the March family. Unfortunately, after Jo turns down his marriage proposal, he runs off to be a shithead playboy in Europe. Various unhappy and spoilery events finally calm him down, and he comes back to the fold as a wiser man, but he's a divisive character, to say the least. Luckily, Harding has half a decade's experience bringing charm and genuine likeability to a slightly skeazy character on Pretty Little Liars. (Plus, CMU alumni REPRESENT!)


JR Bourne as Professor Bhaer


The other leg of Jo's love triangle, Bhaer is an incredibly smart man who, due to his immigrant status, can't get the kind of work he deserves in America. He is staid, but tender, and Jo is drawn to him because he treats her as an intellectual equal. Like all "other legs" of love triangles, a sizeable portion of the fanbase hates him, but whatever. Anyway, Bourne's ace at calm-but-intense, and he's attractive and likeable enough that the CW might be able to overlook the (canonical!) age difference

Sunday, June 21, 2015

Gender Disparity in American Showrunners: Another Descent into Excel Madness

A couple of years ago, I published an in-depth look at the gender make-up of British and American TV writing staffs, with a particular emphasis on sci-fi/fantasy shows. In that case, I was looking for data to justify yelling about Steven Moffat. Alas, the data did not bear me out on that one, so I was forced to yell about Steven Moffat for other reasons.

Anyway, since then I've thought a lot about the kinds of entertainment questions that can be answered with publicly available data. It probably shouldn't have taken me two years to get from "gender disparity in writing staffs" to "gender disparity in showrunners," but in my defense, "Day of the Doctor" aired three months after that post, and the frothing rage it inspired sort of blasted everything else out of my mind.

But I've now mostly recovered, so I decided to do a deep dive into the gender make-up of American showrunners. And as an extra-special Father's Day gift to my dad, who believes I would be the most popular blogger in the world if I would just cut down on the f-bombs, I will not swear a single time.

The Study

I looked at every primetime, scripted show that aired on an American broadcast network (ABC, CBS, the CW, Fox, or NBC) in the 2014 - 15 season. This left out reality shows and soap operas. For each show, I recorded the names of its showrunner(s), whether it had at least one female showrunner, and whether it had at least one male showrunner. My data was gathered from Wikipedia and several dozen (probably over one hundred) interviews and news articles.

Studies should have specific questions going in. In keeping with the sci-fi/fantasy theme of my 2013 study, mine were: What percentage of American TV shows have at least one female showrunner? Are some networks more gender-equal than others? Are some genres more gender-equal than others?

Definitions

"Showrunner" is an uncredited role on American television productions. The showrunner, usually credited as an executive producer, is in charge of the day-to-day running of the show--as you might expect. This also generally makes them the ultimate authority on the creative direction of the show; they decide on long-term plotlines, assign and revise scripts, and incorporate notes from executives.

Because most shows have numerous executive producers, figuring out which one is the showrunner when you are unfamiliar with the show can be a tricky business. Showrunners are often, but not always, the creator of the show. In the end, I just googled extensively. If a preponderance of news articles/interviews named a person as a showrunner, I went with that. I used a combination of names and publicly available photos to determine gender. This is not a 100% foolproof system, but it's the best I have.

As always, the full data set is available for those interested: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1dEHsyl4yJOgpXthrbJdSdr7UiHdWdOK6pfpWvLGYB2k/edit?usp=sharing

The Breakdown

Edit: A concerned reader pointed out that my tables are less than clear. (Thanks, concerned reader!) To clarify: The second column in each table lists the number of shows in each category; the third column lists the number of shows with at least one female showrunner in each category; the fourth column lists the number of shows with at least one male showrunner in each category; and the final column lists the percentage of shows with at least one female showrunner (that is, female showrunner shows divided by total shows) in each category. The third and fourth columns may sum to more than the total number of shows, because some shows have more than one showrunner.

Network
# Shows
# w/ Female SR
# w/ Male SR
% w/ Female SR
ABC
24
12
15
.5
CBS
24
4
21
.167
The CW
11
6
7
.545
Fox
17
4
15
.235
NBC
17
2
15
.118
Total
93
28
73
.301




Genre
# Shows
# w/ Female SR
# w/ Male SR
% w/ Female SR
Comedy
35
8
29
.229
Procedural
21
2
19
.095
Drama
19
11
11
.579
Sci-Fi/Fantasy
18
7
14
.389
Total
93
28
73
.301


So...?

So, 30.1 percent--or slightly less than 1/3--of American network primetime scripted shows have a female showrunner. Meanwhile, 78.5 percent--just over 3/4--of shows have a male showrunner. (Those numbers don't sum to 100 because some shows have multiple showrunners.)

Obviously, those aren't great numbers. Three times as many shows have a male showrunner as have a female showrunner, On the other hand, they're not unexpected numbers; in my 2013 writers room study, I found that the average American show had a writing staff that was 33.4 percent female. And the actual ratio--that is, the total number of credited female writers on American television, divided by the total number of credited writers--was .317, which is extraordinarily close to the showrunners number.

In some ways, that's good news. TV writers' rooms act as a kind of training ground for showrunners; most showrunners have put in at least a few years writing for someone else's show before they're handed the reins of their own. If 31.7 percent of TV writers are female, and 30.1% of showrunners are female, that's an indication that showrunners are drawn with relative gender equality from the pool of qualified TV writers.

Of course, that just means that the problem for women isn't getting out of the writers' room--it's getting into it.

What About Those Network and Gender Questions?

Right! Well, I'll start with genre. Right off the bat, you can see what I'm going to call our "problem genres": comedy and procedurals. Meanwhile, dramas are the best out of any genre, and do better than any individual network; they have total gender equality. Sci-fi/fantasy, my old frenemy, rides the fence; 38.9 percent of SFF shows have a female showrunner, which is juuuuuust above the average.

The networks show a starker divide. ABC and The CW both have 50 percent or more of their shows with a female showrunner; all the other networks have less than 25 percent, with NBC showing an especially dismal 11.8 percent.

Correlation is not, of course, causation, but if I had to hazard a guess, I'd say that the network numbers go a long way toward explaining the genre numbers. ABC and The CW, the two networks with the best gender equality, account for 13 of the 18 SFF shows, and they account for all of the SFF shows with a female showrunner. CBS, meanwhile, the second-worst network, accounts for 2/3 of all procedurals--the worst genre. Though it is possible, I suppose, that networks are first specializing in genres, and then the gender biases of the genres are determining the networks' make-up, the reverse seems more likely.

But again, correlation is not causation. That SFF number is interesting to me, because back in 2013, SFF shows were also just slightly above the average in terms of female writers--but at the time, SFF shows were much more spread out among the five networks. Also interesting: CBS has only two dramas, but those dramas both have female showrunners. And among procedurals, only CBS has any female showrunners.

There are methods by which we might try to suss out the causation, but unfortunately, they rely on us having more data than we do. The fact that there are only two shows that are both dramas and on CBS makes it difficult to figure out how "drama" interacts with "CBS."

But... But Conclusions!

Fine, fine, you can have conclusions. No matter what the causation, it's still a fact that ABC and The CW are doing better than the other networks in terms of gender equality. And it's a lot easier for a network--a defined entity with a relatively small number of decision-makers who regularly communicate--to enact purposeful change than it is for a genre to do so. So if we want more gender equality among showrunners, the thing to do seems to be to applaud ABC and The CW, both with words and with viewership. Make an effort to watch shows with female showrunners, and then write publicly about why you're doing so.

Now, go out there and watch TV!

Thursday, May 14, 2015

Five Things About Elementary 3x24, “A Controlled Descent”

1.  Elementary is about to tell the last important story it will ever tell. Or, more accurately: Elementary may be about to tell the last important story it can ever tell. The threat of relapse has been looming over Sherlock’s story since season one, but it can only be deployed effectively once. This is the last major shift that can happen in these characters’ lives organically; after this, it’s almost inevitable that Elementary will have to work harder and harder to raise the stakes, as nearly all procedurals eventually do. On the other hand, Sherlock’s relapse has the potential to be a phenomenal story. Elementary has always shone when it dealt with addiction, and never more so than in season three. I am excited (and anxious) to see what happens in season four.

2.  After the first half of this season’s return to strong arc-based storytelling, the second half has been a disappointment. Andrew’s death and Joan’s subsequent emotional upheaval were promising (if not particularly original) narrative ground, but though Elementary never exactly abandoned that thread, it never really went anywhere with it, either. I had hoped that Joan’s story would come to a head in the season finale, but it was never mentioned at all, so I guess “One Watson, One Holmes” is the end of that arc. That’s unfortunate, since it was the clearest serialized story of the back half of season three, and without a connection to it, Sherlock’s relapse seems to come out of nowhere. Or, not exactly nowhere—Elementary has been laying a lot of character groundwork for it this season, mostly while the audience was looking in the other direction—but it does feel disconnected, which draws away from the impact of what is otherwise a good story decision. For instance, Alfredo’s abduction would have worked a lot better as a motivator if he’d been in more than two episodes this season.

3. Just so we’re clear, Sherlock’s relapse = the original Holmes’ Reichenbach Falls. Obviously. I mean, the episode is called “A Controlled Descent.” Elementary is not the kind of show where the main characters can fake their deaths, so they had to get metaphorical about it. I was so sure we were going to get Moriarty when I saw the title.

4. Speaking of which: MORIARTY MORIARTY MORIARTY MORIARTY MORIARTY. Come on, Natalie Dormer, what’s Game of Thrones giving you? Prestige? Cable salary? Awesome clothes? Elementary can give you the 5,000 people in the world who scream in joy when they hear your voice.

5. As a standalone episode of television, “A Controlled Descent” is good, but doesn’t break the top five of the season. (In chronological order: “Bella,” “The Illustrious Client”/“The One That Got Away,” “For All You Know,” “One Watson, One Holmes.”) I haven’t tried watching them back-to-back yet, but I’d bet it’s exquisite if viewed as a distant sequel to “For All You Know.” Together, they form a two-sided view of Sherlock-as-addict (the harm he did to others, and the harm he and others did to himself), and provide an emotional context for his relapse.


Saturday, December 20, 2014

Queer Representation in American Children’s Television: A Timeline

SPOILERS below for the series finale of The Legend of Korra.

---

I’m so freaking psyched about the Legend of Korra finale. I mean, so psyched. Happy-crying, talking excitedly to my cat, reckless-blogging psyched. Plausible deniability or not, it takes a lot of stretching and assumptions to convince yourself that the final shots of the series were not meant to indicate a romantic relationship between Korra and Asami. (If you disagree, okay, but I’m not here to argue the point—others have already done so much better than I could.) And while some people are disappointed by the lack of 100 percent bulletproof evidence of that relationship—a kiss, or a line of dialogue, or something—I think that rather misses the incredible importance of what did happen.

With all of the gay, lesbian, and bisexual characters that currently appear on TV (and make no mistake, there are a lot of them—maybe not enough, but more than anyone could have imagined a decade ago) I think people forget that, in the world of children’s television, things have not progressed nearly so far. And while Korra aged up a lot in its final seasons, it was, ultimately, a children’s show. The series finale aired on Nicktoons. It’s rated TV-Y7.

To give people an idea of the context that makes the Korra ending so important, then, I’ve created a timeline of queer representation in American children’s television. It’s probably incomplete, and it’s definitely short. I have not watched every children’s show ever to air in America, so it’s possible that some of the “firsts” I’ve listed are not, in fact, the first of their kind. I welcome any additions or corrections you might have; feel free to leave them in the comments, preferably with a link to a source. My hope is that this timeline will show people the shoulders on which the Korra finale stands, show how far we’ve come and how far we have yet to go, and explain to my sister why, exactly, I woke her up at 6 a.m. EST to flail and cry about some cartoon she’s never heard of.

Definitions

I’ve said it before, and I’ll say it again: Define your terms, people! For the purposes of this timeline, I’m defining a children’s series as any series aimed at viewers under the age of 13, OR any series airing on Nickelodeon, The Disney Channel, or Cartoon Network. “Queer representation” is a little trickier; I’m including characters who are confirmed by writers/actors/executives as being not straight, characters in a same-sex relationship with intentional cues that the viewers should read as romantic, and of course any characters who explicitly describe themselves as gay, lesbian, bisexual, or otherwise not straight. I’m not including “coded gay” characters with no romantic plotlines. Obviously there is a lot of blurriness in this area, and I’ve attempted to give as much context as possible for each example.

1998

February 7: The Superman: The Animated Series episode “Apokolips…Now!, Part 1” airs on The WB during its Saturday morning block. In the episode, Maggie Sawyer is hospitalized, and an unnamed woman stands at her bedside. Co-creator Bruce Timm confirms in audio commentary that the woman is Toby Raines, Sawyer’s girlfriend in the DC Comics universe.

November 18: The Hey Arnold! episode “Arnold’s Thanksgiving” airs on Nickelodeon. In the episode, Arnold and Helga visit their teacher Mr. Simmons’ (voiced by out gay actor Dan Butler) house on Thanksgiving, and witness an argument between Simmons’ mother and a character called Peter that implies that Peter and Simmons are in a relationship. Peter tells Simmons’ mother that there are “a lot of things [she] wasn’t expecting,” to which Simmons’ mother looks affronted. She tells Simmons that he should take his friend Joy to the ballet over the weekend, and Simmons, after glancing at an extremely displeased Peter, says he has other plans. Later, Peter offers Simmons’ mother stuffing; she asks him what he means by that. Though nobody in the episode ever explicitly mentions that Peter and Simmons are romantically linked, nor is the possibility that characters of the same sex could be romantically linked mentioned, this is an unprecedented level of canon indication that two characters are in a same-sex relationship. Mr. Simmons’ relationship with Peter achieves approximately the same level of in-universe confirmation as Helga’s mother’s alcoholism.

2003

Unknown Date: Greg Weisman, co-creator and producer of the 1994 – 1997 Disney/ABC cartoon Gargoyles, confirms in an interview that character Lexington was envisioned as gay, but that attempts to address this subject on the show would not have made it to air.

2004

February 28: In an online chat, Hey Arnold! creator Craig Bartlett confirms that supporting character Robert Simmons is gay, and that his scenes in the episode “Arnold’s Thanksgiving” were an acknowledgement of that.

October 22/November 27: In the third-season episode “Game, Set Up and Match,” animated series Braceface contains a plotline in which the main character tries to set up her male friend Dion with another man, Houston. The set-up fails, as neither Dion nor Houston is interested in having a relationship at the time. Dion never explicitly confirms his attraction to men, but Houston references having an ex-boyfriend. The fact that Dion declines to date Houston not because he’s another man, but because Dion is happy alone at the moment (along with the many, many ways in which Dion is coded gay) has generally been taken as confirmation of Dion’s sexuality. The episode’s final shot is a pan up to a rainbow in the sky overhead. Braceface was set, created, and initially aired in Canada on Teletoon. In the U.S., the Disney Channel aired the first two seasons, but dropped the third. But, to my knowledge, all three seasons aired on ABC Family in the Saturday morning block. The episode is therefore the first overtly romantic plotline between two characters of the same sex to air on U.S. children’s television.

2005

March 10: 2000 – 2004 WB animated series Static Shock co-creator Dwayne McDuffie confirms on his message board that Rich Foley (based on the canonically gay character Rick Stone from the comics on which the show was based) was envisioned as gay: “It'll never come up in the show because it's Y-7 but as far as I'm concerned, Richie is gay.”

2012

November 5: Greg Weisman, co-creator of the 2010 – 2013 Cartoon Network series Young Justice, confirms that he considers some of the series’ characters to be not straight, but that he is unable to portray that on air: “I also believe we have differently oriented characters in the series, even though we're not allowed to mention it out loud. (And just to be sure, I checked to see if we were allowed, and got a no answer. Everyone seems to want to get there, but we're not there yet.)”

2014

January 26: The Disney Channel series Good Luck Charlie airs the episode “Down a Tree,” in which parents Amy and Bob arrange a playdate for their daughter Charlie with a friend, Taylor, from preschool. Amy and Bob each claim to have met Taylor’s mother, but Amy insists the woman’s name is Susan, while Bob is sure that her name is Cheryl. When Taylor arrives, her parents are two women, Susan and Cheryl. Susan and Cheryl are the first same-sex parents ever depicted on American children’s television.

August 7: Olivia Olson, the voice actor for Marceline on the Cartoon Network series Adventure Time, states at a book signing that Marceline and Princess Bubblegum are ex-girlfriends, but that the relationship could never be addressed explicitly within the show. She later tweets, “I like to make things up at panels. Ya’ll take my stories way too seriously…” The tweet is deleted and nothing further is said on the subject by anyone on the Adventure Time creative team. Together with numerous small moments in canon (most notably the episode “Sky Witch,” in which Bubblegum sleeps in a shirt given to her by Marceline), this is taken by fans as indication that Bubblegum and Marceline are canonically romantically linked.

October 23: The Cartoon Network series Clarence airs the episode “Neighborhood Grill.” The episode contains a brief scene in which a woman (Ms. Baker, the titular character’s teacher) waits for her blind date to arrive at a restaurant. She sees a man enter and look around, and believes him to be her date. Instead, the man greets another man, kisses him on the cheek, and walks off with him arm-in-arm. Writer Spencer Rothbell explained on Twitter that the original plan for the scene was for the first man to show up with flowers, and for the two men to kiss on the mouth. Despite the censorship, Clarence is the first children’s TV show to air a romantic same-sex kiss of any kind.

 December 19: The Legend of Korra two-part series finale “Day of the Colossus”/”The Last Stand” airs on Nicktoons. In the show’s final scenes, main character Korra talks to her long-time close friend Asami, and they confirm their need to have each other in their lives. The two agree to go on vacation together, alone. The two women set off into the portal to the Spirit World (their destination of choice), and take each other’s hand. In the final shot of the series, they turn to each other, take both hands, and stare into each other’s eyes. The scene contains several overt parallels to the ending of Korra’s predecessor series, The Last Airbender, in which main character Aang and his long-term love interest Katara finally kiss: the characters are framed in the same way, and a refrain from “The Avatar’s Love” (the theme that played behind Aang and Katara’s kiss) plays over the scene. Though Korra and Asami do not kiss, and never explicitly mention that they are together, the framing, timing, and body language of the final scene heavily imply it. The majority of fans and news outlets consider this canon confirmation that Korra and Asami are romantically linked. Series co-creator Michael Dante Dimartino posts (without commentary) links to several news articles and blog posts that talk about Korra and Asami’s romantic relationship. Korra becomes the first main character on children’s television to have even a semi-canonical same-sex relationship.

Milestones Not Yet Reached

To my knowledge, only one character in all of U.S. children’s television has ever categorized themselves explicitly as something other than straight: Braceface’s Houston, when he mentions having an ex-boyfriend. On Braceface, Dion never says that he’s gay (or bisexual, for that matter), and on Good Luck Charlie, Susan refers to Cheryl as “Taylor’s other mom,” rather than “my wife” or even “my partner.” For some reason, even as it has become increasingly acceptable to portray gay, bisexual, and otherwise queer characters on children’s shows, and even to confirm same-sex relationships with just about every contextual clue possible, actually saying the word "gay" remains taboo.

There are two kinds of same-sex couples that have so far appeared on American kids’ shows: Long-term, developed couples whose romantic relationship is hinted at, rather than 100 percent confirmed (Korra and Asami, Marceline and Princess Bubblegum, and Mr. Simmons and Peter, in varying degrees), and one-off, ancillary couples whose relationship is more explicit (Susan and Cheryl, the Clarence couple). It seems that the next big step in children’s television is to have a recurring same-sex couple whose relationship is overtly romantic.

And of course, though we tend to talk about LGBT representation as one big, globular thing, there's been essentially no trans representation in children's television in the U.S. Given that gay and bisexual representation is lagging several decades behind adult television, I imagine that will remain the case for a while.

Overall, though, 2014 has been a big year for queer representation in kids' TV. When milestones cluster up like this, it's a good sign. It means that the successes we're seeing now are not one-offs, are not flukes, but are in fact a trend. Despite the censorship, the network demands, the general sense that gay and bisexual characters should be at most alluded to, children's TV isn't just running in place; it's taking real steps towards diversity and representation. And for that, we can thank creators like Michael Dante Dimartino and Bryan Konietzko, like Craig Bartlett, like Greg Weisman, like Melissa Clark, who are fighting against a huge wall of institutional inertia to bring that diversity to the screen.
 
Thank you, all of you, so much. You have no idea how much it's appreciated.

Monday, March 31, 2014

I'm not even sure I have a word for this emotion.

There are plenty of riveting, painful moments in this week's Good Wife episode “The Last Call”—almost too many to count—and I wish I could talk about all of them. Despite having one strong A-plot and two clear subplots, one for each of the women most affected by Will’s death, it was largely an episode of moments. Narrative stepped aside in favor of raw emotion and microscopic detail. I don’t mean this as a bad thing. It’s more or less what Buffy the Vampire Slayer did in “The Body” (there’s a comparison everyone and their mother’s made), and it works. If you want to realistically portray the immediate aftermath of an unexpected loss, well, that’s just about the only way to do it, and The Good Wife does it well. Incredibly well.

It does mean, though, that it’s difficult to talk about everything that went into making the episode good, because more than narrative, more than A-plots and B-plots and arcs and resolutions, the episode relies on each and every individual moment being realistically written, heartbreakingly acted, and intensely personal. Every scene has to give us a slightly different but no less real perspective on the central tragedy than the one that came before; a single false note can throw us out of the episode. (For some people, that false note was the conversation Alicia had with her daughter about God. I loved that scene, personally, but the reasons why would probably constitute a blog post all their own, or, if I were going to be really clear about it, a memoir. For some people, the false note was Kalinda, and well, as with all things Kalinda, that's also its own post.)

Instead, I’d like to focus on one particular moment, out of the many. I’m not sure I’d call it the best moment, though it’s certainly a contender, but I do think it’s the most interesting one. It’s about a minute into the episode: Alicia, who was about to introduce Peter at a correspondents’ luncheon when Eli gave her the news of Will’s death, leaves, and Eli must take her place introducing Peter. Unfortunately, he’s still reading off a teleprompter of Alicia’s speech, which is full of references to Alicia’s dress, her children, her marriage to Peter, etc. Eli is shaken, and can’t quite figure out how to stop reading from the teleprompter.

I have never reacted to anything I’ve seen or read, ever, the way I reacted to that scene. It was an entirely novel experience for me. I started laughing and crying simultaneously, the two feeding off each other. It was funnier because it was so painful; it hurt deeper because it was so funny. It wasn’t cathartic, the way joking about a personal tragedy can be, nor did it have the sting and edge of dark humor. It didn’t break the tension, and I didn’t come out of it feeling any better. It was just—this joke, this perfectly normal joke that could conceivably be worked into any episode of The Good Wife, but it was here, instead, and somehow it was massively funny without breaking the tone of the episode, and without providing a single moment’s pause in my grief as a viewer. It’s not the moment in the episode I relate to most personally—those moments all belong to Alicia—but later, when the episode was over and I was talking to my sister, it was talking about that moment that made me cry, really cry, over what I’d just watched.

Quite simply, it was the most Good Wife thing The Good Wife has ever done. There’s not another show on television, now or in history, that could’ve pulled it off. Buffy couldn’t have pulled it off. Not because Buffy didn’t have the skill, although it took enormous skill to make the moment work, but because it’s just not what Buffy is. It was a triumph of tone, five years in the making. And if I still had any doubt, it’s proved to me once and for all that The Good Wife is the best it’s ever been—and that The Good Wife’s best is among the best television has to offer.

Monday, March 24, 2014

Honestly, I'm surprised I was coherent enough to blog about this.

SPOILERS for the most recent episode of The Good Wife, for the most recent season of Game of Thrones, and for major plot elements of Buffy the Vampire Slayer and House.

--

It’s kind of weird to me that people keep comparing the latest episode of The Good Wife to Game of Thrones’ “Red Wedding.” The Red Wedding, though obviously shocking to those who hadn’t read the books, was fundamentally a follow-through of the series’ basic premise. Sudden deaths of major characters are written into GoT’s DNA. They’re inextricable. They’re part of the package.

The death of The Good Wife’s Will Gardner, on the other hand, is a swerve. Nobody could have predicted it. The show has never done anything like it before in four and a half seasons. Viewers simply do not sit down to an episode of The Good Wife prepared for the idea that a main character might die. On the one hand, that makes the death truly shocking; it leaves viewers shaken in a way that a death on Scandal or Lost, shows that are built on twists and sudden deaths, simply can’t. On the other hand, it runs the risk of being too shocking, and making viewers feel tricked or betrayed.

Perhaps unsurprisingly, I’ve seen a certain amount of both reactions to Will’s death. As far as I can tell, the latter is primarily from bitterly disappointed Will/Alicia shippers, who seem to have felt they were promised or owed either a successful Will/Alicia relationship, or that Will would not die, or that Will would die in a certain way, if he ever did.

Every TV show makes an unwritten contract with its viewers: “This is the kind of show I am. These are the lines I can’t cross.” The Good Wife has only ever made two promises. First, it promised to take place in a reality very close to ours, one where not only will fantastical things not happen, but events will have realistic and long-term consequences. Alicia’s not going to run into a dragon or a witches’ coven, but equally importantly, if Peter ever has another affair and it’s publicized, his polling numbers are going to drop drastically.

Second, The Good Wife promised to be a show about Alicia. It promised to follow her, to examine her, to watch her grow. If Alicia ever leaves The Good Wife, it will cease, in some fundamental way, to be the same show.

That’s it. That’s all it promised its viewers. It never promised Will/Alicia as the endgame. It never promised that any character other than Alicia would live, and it never promised that there would be a warning if one of them died.

Other shows have pulled off, or almost pulled off, turns this surprising, this late in the game. Buffy the Vampire Slayer created a little sister out of thin air four years into its run, and the ensuing season was arguably the best the show ever did. Half of House’s main characters quit their jobs in its third season finale, and though the show went downhill after that, it wasn’t the change that did it, but the refusal to change—all three characters remained fixtures on the show for years to come, long after they’d stopped serving a narrative purpose.

It’s about follow-through. Buffy’s monumental twist worked because the show can be neatly split into two eras: pre-Dawn and post-Dawn. The show was never the same again. House’s, on the other hand, failed, because the writers tried to drastically change the characters’ world without actually changing the show. If The Good Wife is to remain the excellent show it’s proved itself to be in the last few seasons, it must forever be a show that is, at least a little bit, about grief and loss. It has to be a changed show, and the changes have to last.

If nothing changes, and the world of The Good Wife goes back to normal after a week or two—or if they start killing off a character every sweeps week—then we can start talking about jumping the shark. For now, though, nothing the show has done has intrinsically broken it. The Good Wife doesn’t owe us anything except what it promised on day one. And the writers don’t owe us anything except the best possible story they can tell. And I’ll tell you this—you can agree with what the Kings did or disagree, like it or dislike it, but you can’t argue that they put anything above the story.